Problems and fixes

Pool Green but Chlorine High: Why It Happens and What to Do

Pool green but chlorine high? Check chlorine against your CYA, rule out metals and test errors, then fix algae with a SLAM. Doses from our calculator.

Jump to the calculator

On this page
  1. First: is your chlorine really high?
  2. Then: check the test itself
  3. Three reasons a pool is green with chlorine in it
  4. Fix algae: SLAM the pool
  5. Fix a metal tint
  6. Green, chlorine high and pH low
  7. When can you swim?
  8. Common mistakes
  9. Track it in Pool Calc
  10. Sources
  11. Safety

The quick answer: if your pool is green, or has algae, but chlorine is high, the chlorine is usually not high enough for your stabilizer (CYA). The more CYA in the water, the more free chlorine (FC) it takes to stop algae: at 80 ppm CYA the minimum is about 6 ppm, so a pool sitting at 5 ppm can still turn green. Test FC and CYA, check the ratio, and if algae is there, SLAM the pool. If the water is clear but tinted green, look at metals instead. Follow the product label for every chemical you add.

FC/CYA calculator

ppm
ppm
3Minimum
6Target
8Upper
16Shock (SLAM)

ppm free chlorine at CYA 40

  • Manual chlorine: minimum is 7.5% of CYA; target adds a 3 ppm cushion for a sunny day.
  • Shock (SLAM) is 40% of CYA, for clearing algae or combined chlorine. It is not a daily level.

Save this test and get reminded when it is time to retest.

Download on the App Store

First: is your chlorine really high?

"High" only means something next to your CYA. TroubleFreePool's Pool School explains that the higher your CYA, the more FC you need, and CDC notes that disinfection takes longer when cyanuric acid is in the water.

CYA (ppm) FC minimum FC target Shock (SLAM) level
30 2.3 5.3 12
50 3.8 6.8 20
80 6 9 32
100 7.5 10 40

If your FC is at or below the minimum for your CYA, algae can grow even though the number looks "high". This is a common reason a pool is green with chlorine in it. If your CYA is very high, see cyanuric acid too high, and the FC/CYA chart has every level.

Then: check the test itself

  • Free vs total chlorine. Total chlorine is free chlorine plus combined chlorine. A high total with low free chlorine means the chlorine is already used up. Read the FC line.
  • Bleached-out tests. CDC notes that above 10 ppm a DPD test can partially or totally bleach out and read falsely low or 0. Taylor Technologies suggests diluting the sample 1:1 with chlorine-free water and multiplying the result by 2.
  • Strips vs drops. CDC notes that test strips are less accurate than DPD test kits. For a green pool, a drop kit that reads FC and CYA is worth it.

Three reasons a pool is green with chlorine in it

1. Algae, because FC is low for the CYA. The water looks cloudy or dull green, and chlorine drops quickly from one day to the next. TroubleFreePool lists a dull look and FC dropping faster than usual as signs of algae. The fix is a SLAM, below.

2. Metals, usually copper. The water looks clear but tinted green, or green to dark stains appear. TroubleFreePool's Pool School lists "emerald green pool water" and green hair as effects of copper, and notes that metal stains commonly appear shortly after pH is raised, often when adding chlorine. Common copper sources it lists are copper algaecides, ionizers and mineral systems, worn copper heat exchangers in heaters, some trichlor products, and rarely the fill water. More chlorine will not clear a metal tint.

3. The green comes back after a shock. Shocking without holding the level is not enough. If chlorine falls back below the minimum for your CYA, algae regrows. A SLAM holds the shock level until the algae is gone.

Fix algae: SLAM the pool

SLAM stands for Shock Level And Maintain. TroubleFreePool's SLAM process works like this:

  1. Test FC, pH and CYA. Adjust pH into about 7.2–7.5 first: the pH test isn't reliable during a SLAM.
  2. Raise FC to the shock level for your CYA, 40% of CYA. For example, raising FC from 5 to 20 ppm in 10,000 gallons at 50 ppm CYA takes about 1.5 gal (5.7 L) of 10% liquid chlorine. With US household bleach at 6%, it is about 2.4 gal (9.2 L). Bleach is sold at 6% to 8.25%, so use the shock calculator with the percentage on your label. Follow the product label.
  3. Hold that level. Test several times a day and top up whenever FC drops. Brush and vacuum daily, run the pump, and clean the filter when its pressure rises about 25% over normal.
  4. Stop when all three are true: combined chlorine is 0.5 ppm or less, you lose 1 ppm of FC or less overnight, and the water is clear with no visible algae.

Log each top-up in Pool Calc for iPhone, and it keeps the SLAM level for your CYA and reminds you when to retest, so the level doesn't slip between tests. The full walkthrough is in green pool water: how to fix it, and how much shock to add to a pool covers each product type.

If CYA is so high that the shock level is out of reach, TroubleFreePool recommends replacing some water first.

Fix a metal tint

  • Test for copper. TroubleFreePool recommends asking for a "total copper" test, because a free copper test misses copper that is held by a sequestrant or sitting in stains.
  • Use a sequestrant to prevent stains. Products based on HEDP or phosphonic acid hold metals so they can't stain, but they don't remove them, and they break down over time, so they need topping up. Follow the product label.
  • Find the source. Stop using copper-based algaecide, and check ionizers, mineral systems and the heater.
  • Replacing water is the only way to remove copper from the pool for good, according to TroubleFreePool.

Green, chlorine high and pH low

When all three show up together, check the pH reading before acting. Taylor Technologies notes that chlorine above about 10 ppm can turn the phenol red pH test blue or purple. Add one drop of the chlorine neutralizer from your alkalinity test to the pH sample and retest. CDC notes that when pH drops, especially below 7.0, pool pipes are more likely to corrode, so raise pH once the reading is reliable. See pool pH too low.

When can you swim?

Not while the pool is green or during a SLAM. Swim when free chlorine is back within your normal range and at or below the re-entry level on your chlorine label (many labels say 4 ppm). Never swim during a SLAM or with free chlorine above 10 ppm. Your product label always comes first. If the problem is high chlorine with clear water, pool chlorine too high covers how to bring it down. For questions about your health, ask your doctor.

Common mistakes

  • Judging chlorine without CYA. 5 ppm can be plenty in one pool and too little in another.
  • Shocking once and stopping. Algae comes back unless the level is held until all three SLAM checks pass.
  • Adding more chlorine to a metal tint. It won't clear it, and raising chlorine can bring stains out.
  • Reading total chlorine as free chlorine. Check which line your test shows.
  • Losing track of top-ups. Pool Calc keeps every reading and dose in one log, so you can see how much chlorine the pool used each day.

Track it in Pool Calc

Pool Calc checks your free chlorine against your CYA, sets the SLAM level for your pool, works out every top-up for the product you use, and tells you when you've passed the combined chlorine and overnight-loss checks. Get Pool Calc for iPhone and log your next test.

One pool? Every feature, free. No account, no ads, and iCloud backup is included.

Sources

Safety

  • Keep chemicals out of reach of children and pets, and keep them out of the water until it is back in range.
  • Never mix chemicals. Never add acid and chlorine together: mixing them releases toxic chlorine gas.
  • Add chemicals to water, never water to chemicals.
  • Store chemicals sealed, cool and dry, apart from each other.
  • Read and follow the product label. It always comes first.

Questions

Why does my pool have algae but chlorine is high?

Usually because the chlorine is not high for your stabilizer (CYA). The more CYA in the water, the more free chlorine you need for the same effect: at 80 ppm CYA the minimum is about 6 ppm, so a reading of 5 ppm is too low to stop algae. Other causes are copper or other metals tinting the water, a test reading total chlorine instead of free chlorine, or a test that bleached out.

Can too much chlorine make a pool green?

Chlorine itself does not turn water green. But if the water holds dissolved metals such as copper, they can show up as a green tint or stains soon after pH or chlorine is raised. TroubleFreePool lists copper algaecides, ionizers, mineral systems and copper heat exchangers as common copper sources.

My pool is green but chlorine is high after shocking. What now?

If the water is cloudy green, the algae is still there and the pool needs a full SLAM: hold free chlorine at the shock level for your CYA, for example 20 ppm at 50 ppm CYA, until the water is clear, combined chlorine is 0.5 ppm or less and you lose 1 ppm or less overnight. If the water is clear but tinted green, suspect metals instead.

My pool is green, chlorine is high and pH is low. What should I do?

First retest pH: chlorine above about 10 ppm can turn the phenol red pH test blue or purple, so add one drop of the chlorine neutralizer from your alkalinity test to the pH sample. CDC notes that low pH makes pool pipes more likely to corrode, so bring pH back up once the reading is reliable, and follow the product label.

Can I swim if my pool is green but chlorine is high?

No. Wait until the water is clear and the chlorine is back in range. Swim when free chlorine is back within your normal range and at or below the re-entry level on your chlorine label (many labels say 4 ppm). Never swim during a SLAM or with free chlorine above 10 ppm. Your product label always comes first.